When Your Custodian Wears Two Hats: A Cautionary Tale About Vessel Repairs, Broker Commissions, and the Limits of Custodia Legis – Century Bank v. M/V Summer 69 (S.D. Fla. May 22, 2026)

In 2019, Marine Biology Research, LLC (MBR) borrowed $5.9 million from Century Bank and pledged two vessels as collateral: a 130-foot Westport luxury motor yacht called the Summer 69 and a 42-foot Scout center-console sportfishing boat. Both were secured by preferred ship mortgages.

MBR defaulted. In August 2023, Century Bank filed suit and had both vessels arrested by the U.S. Marshal. The bank then asked the court to appoint a company called National Liquidators, a well-known marine repossession and auction firm, as substitute custodian to care for the vessels during the litigation.

Century Bank didn’t just hire National Liquidators to watch the boats. It also hired National Liquidators as its exclusive sales broker, agreeing to pay a 6% commission on whatever the vessels fetched at auction. National Liquidators thus wore two hats from day one: court-appointed guardian of the vessels, and commissioned salesman with a financial incentive to maximize their value.

To make matters more complicated, shortly after arrest, lightning struck the Summer 69, leaving it unseaworthy with significant damage to its electrical systems, engine computers, and battery banks. MBR, the borrower, did nothing to fix it.

In May 2024, the court granted Century Bank summary judgment on the mortgages and entered a final judgment of $6,438,103.31. In August 2024, the U.S. Marshal auctioned both vessels. The yacht sold for $5.6 million and the Scout for $295,000. After the Marshal’s commission, Century Bank received $5,837,498.34, an amount well short of the judgment. The bank then returned to court seeking to add the shortfall through a series of additional claims: more storage and maintenance costs, a broker’s commission, attorney’s fees, and additional interest bringing its total ask to over $2.25 million in further recovery.

The magistrate judge held a multi-day evidentiary hearing with nearly 100 exhibits and multiple expert witnesses, then issued a detailed report recommending the bank recover approximately $1.97 million. The magistrate judge granted some claims in full, trimmed others significantly, and rejected others outright.

1. Custodia Legis — The Court’s Power Over Custodial Expenses

Under federal admiralty law, when a vessel is arrested and placed under court supervision, the expenses of caring for that vessel are treated as “expenses of justice” and are paid out of the sale proceeds ahead of all other liens, including preferred ship mortgages. The idea is that someone has to pay to keep the boat from sinking while the lawyers argue.

But there are important limits. Southern District of Florida Local Admiralty Rules require that a substitute custodian’s job is to maintain an arrested vessel in its existing condition, not to improve it. And critically, any non-emergency repairs require prior court approval. A custodian who makes improvements without permission risks losing priority or losing the expense claim entirely.

National Liquidators largely ignored these rules. Its emails, introduced at the hearing, showed the firm wasn’t preserving the vessels. Rather it was preparing them for retail sale. Emails referenced “making a prep list to get ready for sale,” “readying the boat for sale,” and arranging sea trials for prospective buyers. The firm replaced control consoles, navigation displays, and four large batteries; cleaned and video-documented the hull; and undertook other significant work all without ever asking the court for permission.

The magistrate judge found these expenses ineligible as custodia legis. The costs were improvements for sale, not preservation of the arrested condition. The court excluded $113,388.18 in non-emergency repair costs from custodial expense treatment.

The court also rejected National Liquidators’ $15,729 in storage fees for the Scout, finding they were 100% profit. The marina charged nothing extra for the Scout’s berth alongside the yacht, and National Liquidators simply invoiced the bank for fees it never paid. Similarly, the court rejected $63,000 in insurance charges because National Liquidators’ representative couldn’t explain at the hearing how the charges were calculated or even what the bank actually paid in premiums.

The legitimate custodia legis expenses, daily custodial fees, actual moorage, routine maintenance, and the custodian’s reasonable 15% contractor markup, were allowed, totaling $178,511.74.

2. The Preferred Ship Mortgage as a Safety Net

Even though the court rejected many of the expenses under the custodia legisdoctrine, it found a separate basis to award them anyway: the language of the preferred ship mortgages themselves.

Both mortgages contained “Additional Advances” provisions, under which MBR agreed that Century Bank could, in its sole discretion, repair the vessels, maintain insurance, and cover storage costs if MBR failed to do so, and that all such advances would be secured by the mortgage lien. The mortgages also contained a broad indemnification clause, requiring MBR to reimburse Century Bank for any expenses arising from the exercise of its rights under the mortgages.

The vessels argued these provisions only applied to non-judicial repossession scenarios, not judicial foreclosure. The court disagreed, pointing to an express “election of remedies” clause allowing the bank to pursue all available remedies simultaneously.

The upshot: even though the non-emergency repairs, Scout storage fees, insurance charges, and the broker’s 6% commission ($353,700) were disqualified as custodia legis expenses, they were all added back into the judgment as mortgage-secured Additional Advances or indemnification obligations. The vessels’ owners (MBR) had contractually agreed to pay for all of it.

3. Attorney’s Fees — Close But Not Quite

The bank sought $209,278.50 in attorney’s fees, authorized by the mortgage documents. The court found the hourly rates reasonable but trimmed the hours by 15% across the board, noting that the vessels had offered essentially no opposition to the lawsuit. They did not contest the arrest or oppose summary judgment, and told the court they were holding back specifically to limit the bank’s fee exposure. The billing records also showed charges for purely administrative tasks and duplicative work by multiple attorneys. The court awarded $177,886.73.

4. Interest — Two Different Rates for Two Different Periods

The promissory notes called for a 21% default interest rate. Century Bank wanted that rate to continue running on the full judgment balance indefinitely. The court said no.

Under federal law (28 U.S.C. § 1961), once a court enters a final judgment, post-judgment interest accrues at the statutory Treasury rate, not the contractual default rate, unless the contract clearly and unambiguously specifies otherwise. The promissory notes here provided for 21% interest upon default, but said nothing about post-judgment interest. That silence was fatal to the bank’s argument.

The court therefore applied three distinct interest periods: the contractual 21% rate from the prior calculation date through the date of judgment; the statutory rate of 5.19% from judgment through the vessel sale; and then a sharply reduced per diem thereafter, recalculated on the remaining deficiency balance after sale proceeds were applied.

The Conclusion

The magistrate judge recommended an Amended Final Judgment of $1,968,558.35, broken down roughly as follows: $178,511.74 in legitimate custodia legis expenses; $546,817.18 in mortgage-based Additional Advances and indemnification (repairs, storage, insurance, broker commission); $177,886.73 in attorney’s fees; $288,192.95 in prejudgment interest at 21%; and $173,189.60 in post-judgment interest at the statutory rate. The court also recommended denying the bank’s request to reserve jurisdiction for future awards. The vessels are sold and gone, and the case should close.

The Takeaway

This case is essential reading for anyone involved in preferred ship mortgage enforcement including lenders, borrowers, custodians, and their counsel alike. Several practical lessons stand out:

Get court approval before making repairs. The local admiralty rules exist for a reason. A substitute custodian who makes non-emergency repairs without prior court authority faces a real risk of losing custodia legis status and priority, and potentially losing the expense claim entirely. The fact that the bank recovered these amounts here was only because the mortgage documents provided an independent legal basis. In a case with competing lienholders, the result could have been much worse.

The “two hats” problem is a real legal risk. Appointing the same firm as both substitute custodian and sales broker creates an inherent conflict. The custodian’s job is to preserve the vessel as-is; the broker’s job is to maximize sale price through improvements. These incentives pull in opposite directions, and courts will scrutinize the resulting expenses carefully.

Draft your mortgage documents to cover enforcement costs explicitly. The reason Century Bank ultimately recovered expenses that failed under custodia legis was because its mortgage documents contained robust Additional Advances and indemnification provisions. Lenders without those provisions could face a much harder fight.

Post-judgment interest follows the statute, not the contract, unless the contract says so clearly. Lenders who want their contractual default rate to continue running after judgment need to say so explicitly in the loan documents. A general default rate provision is not enough.

Get brokerage agreements approved in advance. Several courts in this district have expressly approved sales brokerage arrangements in arrested vessel cases. There was no reason for Century Bank to forego that step. Court approval would have mooted the entire dispute over the $353,700 commission.

Marina Wins on Liability, But Court Sends It Back to Do the Math — Harbour Towne SMI Opco, LLC v. M/Y “Lady Cher L C’s” (S.D. Fla. May 17, 2026)

In January 2015, a Fort Lauderdale-area marina called Harbour Towne entered into a dockage contract with James Muskal, the owner of a 2005 55-foot motor yacht called the Lady Cher L C’s. For nearly a decade, the arrangement apparently worked. The owner paid and the marina provided dockage, electricity, and other services. In May 2024, the payments stopped.

By the time Harbour Towne filed suit in federal court, it claimed $61,059.06 in unpaid dockage and marina services. The marina had the vessel arrested by the U.S. Marshal in May 2025 and served as the court-appointed substitute custodian racking up an additional $101,571.64 in court-supervised storage costs through January 2026.

RBC Centura held a First Preferred Ship Mortgage on the vessel totaling over $358,000. RBC showed up in the case to protect its mortgage interest and argued that its mortgage outranked Harbour Towne’s lien. The vessel owner himself never appeared in court at all, and a default was entered against the vessel.

The case presented two main issues:

1. Did the marina have a valid maritime lien?

Under the Commercial Instruments and Maritime Lien Act (CIMLA), 46 U.S.C. § 31342 anyone who provides “necessaries” to a vessel at the direction of the owner automatically acquires a maritime lien on that vessel. “Necessaries” is broadly defined and includes dockage, storage, electricity, repairs, and supplies, i.e. anything the vessel needs to keep operating. The lien attaches to the vessel itself, not just the owner personally, which is what makes it so powerful: you can sue the boat.

2. How much could the marina actually recover?

This turned out to be the more complicated question, and the one where the marina ran into trouble.

The court ruled in Harbour Towne’s favor. The marina provided dockage and other services under a signed contract with the vessel’s owner, the owner paid without complaint for nine years, and then stopped. That’s a textbook maritime lien for necessaries.

On damages, the court pumped the brakes. Several of Harbour Towne’s claimed charges didn’t hold up to scrutiny:

The $50 monthly late fee billed to the owner was not recoverable because it isn’t a “necessary” provided to the vessel; it’s a penalty for nonpayment.

The original 2015 contract called for a daily fee of $99.11. The invoices submitted with the motion reflected daily rates of $147 to $156 which was significantly higher. The court acknowledged rates may have legitimately increased over a decade, but the marina provided no explanation or documentation for the discrepancy. Without that, the higher rates couldn’t be awarded.

The marina’s invoices included line items of $3,620 for “Attorney Fees” and $4,000 for “Attorney/US Marshal Fee.” The court rejected both. Attorney’s fees are not necessaries under maritime law, and the U.S. Marshal deposit is only recoverable to the extent the marshal actually spent the money and not as a flat reimbursement of whatever was deposited.

The marina’s $101,571.64 in post-arrest storage and maintenance costs were legally recoverable, and they take priority over other claims, but the court ruled the request was premature because the vessel hadn’t been sold yet. Harbour Towne can file for those costs after the sale.

The marina is entitled to interest on the unpaid balance running from May 1, 2024 (when payments first went delinquent) through the date of the vessel’s sale.

The court entered judgment on liability but ordered Harbour Towne to file a corrected damages submission by May 29, 2026, warning that failure to do so would result in dismissal.

This case is a useful reminder that winning on liability is only half the battle in a maritime lien enforcement action. The damages phase has its own pitfalls, and courts scrutinize maritime lien invoices carefully.

Several practical lessons emerge. Don’t bundle attorney’s fees or penalty charges into your lien invoices because they won’t be recoverable and can undermine your credibility on the amounts that are legitimate. If your rates have increased since the original contract was signed, document the basis for those increases. A simple rate-update amendment or notice to the vessel owner goes a long way.

Courts will only award what the Marshal actually spent. If you deposited $3,500 or $4,000 and the Marshal didn’t spend all of it, you need to show actual disbursements.

Custodia legis costs are legitimate and priority-ranked, but they’re awarded from sale proceeds and not as part of a pre-sale damages judgment. Time your motion accordingly.

The priority dispute between Harbour Towne’s maritime lien and RBC’s preferred ship mortgage wasn’t resolved in this opinion. That fight will happen after the vessel is sold and the proceeds are distributed. In general, maritime liens for necessaries that predate a preferred ship mortgage take priority over the mortgage. Whether that applies here will depend on when Harbour Towne’s lien first attached which is a question likely to generate further litigation.

The Law Office of Alexander T Gruft handles maritime lien enforcement, marina disputes, and admiralty litigation. Contact us to discuss your matter.

Court Orders Sale of Arrested Nigerian Barge After Owner Fails to Act — A Cautionary Tale for Vessel Owners – Int’l Ship Repair & Marine Services, Inc. v. Formerly B (M.D. Fla. May 1, 2026)

In 2024, a Nigerian shipping company called Herald Marine & Energy arranged to berth its aging deck cargo barge at International Ship Repair and Marine Services (ISR), a Tampa-area ship repair facility. Herald Marine would pay dockage fees while it organized a crew to sail the vessel back to Nigeria. The crew never came. The fees went unpaid.

In June 2025, ISR filed a federal maritime lawsuit and had the U.S. Marshal arrest the vessel under court supervision with ISR serving as its custodian. From the date of arrest through March 2026, the barge racked up over $832,000 in court-supervised storage costs, on top of the nearly $841,000 Herald Marine already owed, bringing the total claim to more than $1.67 million. This amount grew at $2,544 per day. Herald Marine, for its part, claimed ISR promised to make certain repairs before the vessel could be moved, but took no meaningful steps to bond the vessel out of arrest or otherwise resolve the situation.

ISR asked the court for an interlocutory sale so it could stop the financial bleeding.

Under the Federal Rules governing admiralty cases (Supplemental Rule E(9)(a)), a court can authorize an early sale of an arrested vessel if any one of three conditions is met: (1) the vessel is deteriorating or perishable; (2) the cost of keeping it is excessive or disproportionate to its value; or (3) there has been an unreasonable delay by the owner in securing its release.

ISR argued two of the three applied here.

The magistrate judge agreed with ISR on both grounds.

On the cost vs. value question, the court noted that the barge was old, and before Herald Marine came along, the only parties who had expressed any interest in buying it were scrap dealers. Spending $2,544 per day to store a vessel of that diminished worth is exactly the kind of “disproportionate” expense the rule is designed to address.

On unreasonable delay, the court observed that courts typically view four to five months post-arrest as the threshold for ordering a sale. Here, over ten months had passed with no resolution. Herald Marine’s vague gestures toward settlement and its unresolved repair dispute did not move the needle.

The court recommended that the U.S. Marshal conduct a public auction within 30 days, with proper notice to the owner, known lienholders, and the public. Sale proceeds would go into the court’s registry, and all claimants, including Herald Marine, would have the chance to argue their priority and entitlement to whatever the vessel fetches.

This case is a stark reminder that inaction is never a safe harbor when your vessel is under maritime arrest. Once a federal court seizes a vessel, the clock starts running on storage costs, on the owner’s window to post a bond or negotiate a release, and on the court’s patience. Four to five months is roughly the outer limit before a court will entertain selling the vessel out from under the owner, regardless of fault disputes. Here, Herald Marine’s delay cost it any meaningful control over the outcome. The vessel will now be sold at public auction to the highest bidder, potentially for scrap value, with ISR’s mounting liens paid first from the proceeds.

For vessel owners and operators: if your vessel is arrested, act immediately. Engage counsel, explore bonding the vessel out of arrest, and engage seriously with the claimant. Delay is expensive, and in admiralty, it can be fatal to your ownership interest.

The Law Office of Alexander T Gruft handles maritime lien enforcement, marina disputes, and admiralty litigation. Contact us to discuss your matter.

Marina Wins Court Battle Over Abandoned Boat — But Doesn’t Get Everything It Asked For – Southport Marina Dev. Co. LLC v. Zozo N’Zaza, (E.D. Wis. May 8, 2026)

What Happened

In the summer of 2023, a Wisconsin marina entered into a winter storage contract with Dr. Joseph Nantomah to haul, store, and winterize his 1990 Silverton motor vessel for $5,500. Dr. Nantomah never paid. The boat sat in the marina’s yard, racking up costs, for nearly two years.

The marina eventually did what marinas in this situation have to do: it filed a federal lawsuit to enforce a maritime lien against the vessel only. Under federal law (46 U.S.C. § 31342), anyone who provides “necessaries” to a vessel, including a storage facility, automatically acquires a lien on the boat itself and can sue the boat in federal court to collect.

The marina arrested the vessel through the U.S. Marshal’s Service, published the required public notice, held an auction, and asked the court to approve a final judgment and authorize a “credit bid” so the marina could bid its own debt at the auction instead of coming up with cash.

Nobody showed up to contest the case.

The Legal Issue

By the time the marina filed its motion for final judgment, the claimed amount had grown from the original $5,500 to over $46,000. The total included unpaid storage fees, court costs, and $13,876 in attorneys’ fees.

The court had no issue with the storage balance or the litigation costs. The sticking point was attorneys’ fees.

What the Court Decided

The court granted the marina a judgment of $32,519.62 to cover the unpaid balance and court costs, and authorized that amount as the credit bid. But it refused to award attorneys’ fees.

Admiralty law has a long-standing rule against fee-shifting. Courts across nearly every federal circuit including the First, Second, Third, Fifth, Ninth, and Eleventh Circuits, have consistently held that each side pays its own lawyers in maritime cases, absent a specific contractual provision or statute saying otherwise. The marina’s lawyers offered no argument for why they should be the exception. The court wasn’t interested in guessing for them.

Takeaway for Marina Operators

This case illustrates how maritime lien enforcement works, and one important limitation on recovery.

The good news: the system works. A marina that provides storage, haul-out, or winterization services has a powerful federal remedy when an owner walks away from a boat. The lien attaches automatically, the boat can be arrested and sold, and the marina can credit bid so it is not forced to find a cash buyer in a thin market.

The limitation: attorneys’ fees are almost certainly not recoverable in a straight admiralty lien case unless your storage contract explicitly provides for them. In this case, the marina spent nearly $14,000 in legal fees that the court refused to award. That’s money left on the table, and a problem that could have been addressed with better contract drafting on the front end.

If your marina storage agreement does not already include a prevailing-party attorneys’ fees provision, now is a good time to revisit it. Whether such a clause would be enforceable in federal admiralty court is a nuanced question — but having the contractual hook is the necessary first step.


This post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Contact a maritime attorney for guidance on your specific situation.

Show Your Work: When a Vessel Arrest Gets Challenged in Court E.R. Truck & Equipment Corp. v. “The Aviatrix” 2026 U.S. Dist. Lexis 94304 (S.D. Fla. Apr. 29, 2026)

Background

East Harbor, a Florida marine equipment and services company, sued the owners of a luxury motor yacht called The Aviatrix, an 88-foot Italian-built Maiora yacht, over an unpaid debt. The defendants were Crystal Marine Ventures Ltd., a British Virgin Islands company, and Julio Marquez, an individual, both named personally alongside the vessel itself.

East Harbor arrested the yacht. When the defendants failed to respond to the complaint, the court clerk entered a default against them in February 2026.

The defendants then showed up. In March 2026, they moved to undo both the default and the vessel arrest.

East Harbor conceded the default issue without a fight, agreeing to let that be vacated. That left one question for the court: should the arrest of The Aviatrix stand?

The defendants argued the arrest should be thrown out for three reasons:

  1. East Harbor did not properly allege a preferred ship mortgage or maritime lien sufficient to give the federal court jurisdiction in the first place.
  2. The claimed defaults on whatever underlying obligation existed were not adequately spelled out in the complaint.
  3. A parallel state court case was already underway that would resolve all the same issues, so the federal court should step aside.

The Law

When a vessel is arrested in a federal admiralty case, the owner has a due process right to a prompt hearing under Supplemental Admiralty Rule E(4)(f). At the hearing, the plaintiff must show the arrest was supported by “reasonable grounds.” Importantly, courts have been clear that this is not a demanding standard, and the Eleventh Circuit has warned district courts not to turn these hearings into a full-blown mini-trial on the merits.

The Result

The court vacated the default (as agreed) but did not rule on the arrest. Instead, it scheduled a live hearing for May 8, 2026, and ordered East Harbor to appear in person and show cause why the arrest should not be lifted. The defendants’ challenge to the arrest remains very much alive.

The Takeaway

This case is a useful reminder of two things that run in opposite directions.

For plaintiffs pursuing vessel arrests: getting a warrant issued is only the beginning. Once the owner appears and demands a hearing, you have to be ready to defend the legal basis for the arrest. The complaint must clearly allege the lien or mortgage giving rise to the claim, and the defaults must be spelled out with enough specificity to survive scrutiny. Sloppy pleading can put the entire arrest at risk.

For vessel owners facing arrest: you have real procedural rights. Even if your boat has already been seized, you can demand an immediate hearing and force the arresting party to justify what it did. If the underlying claim is thin or poorly pled, a prompt challenge can get the arrest vacated and your vessel back before the case reaches the merits.

This post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Contact a maritime attorney for guidance on your specific situation.

When the Person Who Sues Doesn’t Own the Boat: A Lesson in Maritime Standing Tomasso v. Peddle, S.D. Tex. (April 20, 2026)

What Happened

Ludovico Tomasso bought a yacht called the Southern Bell in 2014. Over the years, ownership of the boat passed through a couple of LLCs. First was a Florida company. Second was a Texas LLC called B.E.L.L. Marine. Tomasso and his then-wife, Bonnie Peddle, were both listed as managers of B.E.L.L.

The marriage fell apart. Tomasso filed for divorce in 2020, and by 2022 a Canadian court finalized the split. During that same period, around the time the divorce was filed, Peddle, acting as president of two Canadian corporations she controlled, filed maritime liens against the Southern Bell totaling over $500,000. The liens claimed the corporations had loaned money for repairs and services on the vessel.

Tomasso sued to invalidate the liens, arguing they were either legally improper maritime liens or barred by the divorce judgment. He claimed the liens were a litigation tactic by his ex-wife to cloud title to the boat.

There was one problem: Tomasso no longer owned the Southern Bell. B.E.L.L. Marine LLC did.

The Legal Issue

Before a federal court can decide who wins a lawsuit, it has to ensure the person suing has standing. To have standing, a plaintiff must show three things: (1) they suffered a real injury, (2) the defendant caused it, and (3) the court can fix it.

Tomasso’s argument was essentially: I live on the boat, therefore I have a right to defend it against these liens. The court wasn’t buying it.

Because Tomasso did not personally own the Southern Bell, any injury from the liens belonged to the LLC, not to Tomasso individually. Tomasso’s role as manager of the LLC did not change that. Under Texas law, an LLC member has no ownership interest in the LLC’s specific property.

Tomasso also argued he had a “right of possession” since the boat was his home since 2020. However, simply living on a vessel, without some formal legal arrangement like a lease or charter agreement, does not create a legally recognized possessory interest.

The court also addressed the type of lawsuit Tomasso filed. A challenge to maritime liens against a vessel is typically brought as an in rem action. The vessel itself is the defendant and must be physically present and seized in the court’s jurisdiction. None of that happened here. The Southern Bell was never arrested or attached.

The court flagged another wrinkle: there’s a well-established maritime law principle that a vessel’s owner, or part owner, cannot hold a maritime lien on their own vessel. If Peddle’s corporations were effectively controlled by someone with an ownership stake in B.E.L.L., the liens might be invalid on that basis alone. The court did not reach that question given the standing problem, but it noted that equity would likely demand “piercing the corporate veil” to prevent insiders from jumping to the front of the creditor line.

Rather than simply throwing the case out, the court gave the real party in interest, B.E.L.L. Marine LLC, the actual owner of the Southern Bell, 21 days to step in and take Tomasso’s place as the plaintiff. If B.E.L.L. does that, the case can proceed as if it had been filed properly from the start. If no one steps in, the entire case gets dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

The Takeaway

This case is a good reminder that in maritime litigation, who brings the lawsuit matters as much as what the lawsuit is about. Even if the underlying lien claims are legally questionable,  the court strongly hinted they might be, a plaintiff without a legally recognized interest in the vessel cannot be heard in federal court. If you want to fight a maritime lien, make sure the vessel’s actual owner is the plaintiff.

Secured By miniOrange