Tomasso v. Peddle, 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 195874 (S.D. Tex. Aug. 31, 2026)

A federal court in Texas recently dismissed a maritime lawsuit not because the legal claims were wrong, but because the company bringing the suit couldn’t get its own house in order. The case is a stark reminder that how you structure the ownership and management of a vessel-owning LLC matters just as much as the merits of your maritime dispute, and that co-managing a company with an ex-spouse creates problems that can run far deeper than the divorce itself.

The Southern Bell is an 82-foot superyacht owned by B.E.L.L. Marine, LLC, a Texas limited liability company. B.E.L.L. was co-managed from inception by two people: Ludovico Tomasso and his then-wife Bonnie Peddle. The marriage ended in a Canadian divorce proceeding. The business relationship did not.

Three parties, a Canadian corporation, a company called Forza 5 Energie, Inc., and an individual named Linda Krantz,  claimed maritime liens against the Southern Bell.

Rather than B.E.L.L., the actual vessel owner, filing suit to challenge those liens, Tomasso filed the lawsuit himself. The court quickly spotted the problem: Tomasso, as an individual, was not the owner of the Southern Bell and had no standing to bring the claims on his own. In April 2026, the magistrate judge recommended dismissal and gave B.E.L.L. 21 days to properly substitute in as plaintiff. The district court adopted that recommendation.

Tomasso’s counsel filed a motion to substitute B.E.L.L. as plaintiff. Peddle, a defendant in the same case, because she was aligned with the parties asserting the liens, opposed the substitution. She argued that as a co-manager of B.E.L.L. she never authorized the company to bring this lawsuit. Under the Texas Business Organizations Code, filing a lawsuit is not an ordinary business decision that one manager can make alone. It requires both managers to agree.

Tomasso fired back with six arguments for why he could act without Peddle’s consent. The court rejected every one of them.

Key Takeaways for Vessel Owners and Maritime Practitioners

Structure your LLC before a dispute arises.

A two-manager LLC with no tiebreaker mechanism is a deadlock waiting to happen. An operating agreement should address what happens when managers disagree, especially on major decisions like litigation. If you are forming a vessel-owning LLC with a partner, build in dispute resolution procedures from day one.

Vessel ownership and LLC membership are legally distinct.

When a vessel is titled to an LLC, the LLC owns the boat — not its members or managers individually. A divorce decree that allocates the “yacht” between spouses does not automatically reorganize who controls the entity that holds the yacht’s title. Proper post-divorce restructuring of the LLC through a formal buyout, membership transfer, and operating agreement amendment is essential.

Filing a lawsuit is not “ordinary business.”

Courts are consistent on this point. Hiring a lawyer and filing suit requires the same authority as any other major company decision. If your LLC operating agreement doesn’t spell out who has litigation authority, assume you need all managers on board.

A conflict of interest does not equal disqualification.

Under Texas law, an interested manager can still vote. If your co-manager is acting against the company’s interests, your remedy is to pursue a breach of fiduciary duty claim or seek a court-supervised resolution — not to simply override their vote.

Tax filings are not governance documents.

Annual reports filed with the state can contain stale or incorrect information. They do not establish who is or is not a manager. Formal removal requires a documented membership meeting and vote, or a resignation in writing.

News

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Secured By miniOrange